York vs. Goodman HVAC: Which Brand is Better?

Kenneth Wilson

Are you currently torn between York or Goodman HVAC products? Let us start by saying that's an excellent question to ask. Both brands are reliable, well-respected names in the HVAC industry.

But, which among the two seems to be the better investment in the long run? The answer will depend on several factors. Depending on the location of your property, you will need HVAC units that are built to perform, especially in extreme heat, humidity, or sea air.

We're here to help you choose between York and Goodman HVAC units, shedding light on the differences you need to be aware of.

Goodman HVAC Units

What we love about Goodman HVAC units:

  • Go-to choice by many homeowners
  • Available low-cost options
  • Compatible with smart homes
  • Best choice for budget shoppers looking for quality products
  • Offers a warranty that replaces the unit

Average Cost to Install Goodman HVAC

Energy Efficiency

$3,400 to $4,700

13 to 18 SEER

Although Goodman HVAC units aren't as reputable as Carrier or Trane, the Goodman brand is another respected name in the market. They are known primarily for their low-cost price tags compared to standard counterparts.

The brand has developed great-quality HVAC products over the years, with some of the most generous warranty programs in the industry today. They design, assemble, and engineer all commercial HVAC systems at their headquarters located outside Houston, Texas, the largest HVAC building in the United States. Many homeowners also prefer the brand's proud USA-centric manufacturing process.

Goodman also manufactures Amana air conditioners, although the latter is commonly marketed as a more premium brand. If you want to save some money, you may want to choose Goodman HVAC units for your home needs. (Related: Goodman vs Trane: Is Trane Worth The Higher Price?)

  • Generous Warranty: The brand offers a limited lifetime warranty on specific compressors, a great warranty coverage compared to the industry's 10-year average. It also comes with either a two- or 10-year unit replacement warranty. Some of its best sellers also have lifetime compressor or heat exchanger warranties.
  • Standard Features: Goodman's air conditioners, in particular, are built with a two-speed condenser motor and two-stage scroll compressors to maintain low humidity levels. It is constructed with a ComfortNet communication system to ensure precision control, with an average SEER rating of 18 for optimal energy efficiency.
  • Focused on Durability: Goodman is renowned for its focus on durability. For instance, it uses Copeland parts in its central air conditioners and heat pumps. Both are enclosed in galvanized steel cases (spray-salt tested for 500 hours), ensuring these units can withstand extreme elements. The brand's furnaces are also notably durable, designed with an aluminized-steel heat exchanger. It is tested at least three times before a Goodman HVAC unit leaves the assembly line.
  • Pricing: Designed to be an affordable HVAC brand, Goodman offers a mid-range series that fits your budget– starting from $2,600 to $5,600. It also has a high-efficiency scroll compressor which keeps your indoor temperature as comfortable as possible.
  • The Downside: With a SEER rating of up to 13, Goodman HVAC units will keep your home adequately cool. However, its rating is considerably lower than other similar models in the market.

York HVAC Units

What we love about York HVAC units:

  • Available lifetime warranty
  • It has low maintenance and repair costs
  • Best for customers on a budget
  • It offers a good warranty

Average Cost to Install York HVAC

Energy Efficiency

$3,500 to $5,800

13 to 18 SEER

HVAC systems from York are another reputable choice, especially with their fair value price points. Their air conditioners, in particular, are renowned for their whisper-quiet operation. So if noise is a genuine concern for you, you may want to look into York's AC line. This brand has a long history of providing refrigeration and cooling needs to consumers.

Compared to other popular HVAC brands like Carrier, York is considerably more affordable. Low-cost HVAC units do not offer the same features as a premium brand. Nonetheless, you can count on the crowd-favorite York HVAC models to offer dependable performance and exceptional durability.

  • Product Line: York offers HVAC products in three series: Affinity, LX, and TC. Affinity models are designed with premium features and energy efficiency, while LX units represent the middle ground. Its entry-level options are the TC models.
  • Energy Efficiency: Many York models have earned the ENERGY STAR certification and the Good Housekeeping Seal, which proves their high efficiency. Naturally, units with higher efficiency will cost you more, but this gives you a lifetime of utility bill savings and increased home comfort.
  • Good Quality: All York units have features that enhance the product's durability, including guardrails to protect the coil and compressor from foreign debris. But, not every unit offers the same value for your money. Base models are the most cost-effective, but they can be less efficient over time. If you're looking for the best buy, consider checking out York's premium Affinity series and LX models.
  • Installation and Warranty: All York HVAC units have a 10-year warranty on both parts and compressor.
  • The Downside: In purchasing a York unit, you need to ensure correct installation if you don’t want to deal with costly, pressing issues in the long run.

The Verdict

Both Goodman and York provide good-quality HVAC units for the average homeowner.

Important Note: The most crucial guarantee of long-term HVAC performance doesn't rely on the brand but on the contractor you hire for its installation and servicing.

In short, there's a rare chance you'll stumble across manufacturer defects when buying from Goodman and York. It would be best to speak to a local contractor to provide a more detailed breakdown of a York vs. Goodman HVAC unit, depending on your unique home needs.

The most important factors to consider before making a purchase are your budget, your home-cooling needs, and the warranty provided.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does Goodman offer a money-back guarantee?

Some Goodman dealers offer money-back guarantees if you're dissatisfied with your Goodman HVAC system within one year of purchase. Before buying your HVAC system, find out what kind of money-back guarantee it comes with and what terms it comes with.

Does York offer a money-back guarantee?

As long as a York-certified contractor installs the equipment, all York HVAC systems come with a 100% money-back guarantee. If you are not satisfied with the product or craft, the company will remove the installed equipment and return your money. Before you buy your system, ask your local HVAC contractor for further information.

How do I contact Goodman customer service?

Filling out the contact form on the company's website is the easiest way to contact Goodman's customer support. You can also message a customer service representative directly by clicking the chat bubble in the lower right corner. You can also get in touch with customer service by calling them now.

How do I contact York’s customer service?

York customer service is available Monday through Friday from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. CST. You may also send an email to a customer service agent. York recommends contacting your local York dealer for specific concerns regarding your equipment or HVAC needs.

When should I have my heating and cooling equipment serviced?

Before starting each heating and cooling season, have your HVAC systems serviced. Your air conditioner should be maintained at the end of winter or the beginning of spring. Meanwhile, the heat pump or furnace should be serviced at the end of summer or the beginning of fall.

How long does HVAC equipment last?

The average lifespan of an HVAC system is 10 to 15 years. However, as your system becomes older, it becomes less efficient and performs poorly. Therefore, you may wish to begin looking for a replacement after about ten years. Modern HVAC systems will save you money on your energy costs even if you don't have any significant issues since they are more efficient.

Kenneth Wilson
May 5, 2022
HVAC, Reviews

Kenneth Wilson

Retired contractor. Currently residing in Southwest Florida. Now in semi-retirement, I write and manage this blog focused on helping home owners make savvy decisions when it comes to finding contractors and getting their projects done. I also operate remodeling design service for homeowners.

Ask The Author Your Question In The Comments!

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

More From This Author

9 of the Best Ring Security Cameras: Home Security 101
Where You Should Place Security Cameras Around Your Home: Best Locations
How Long Do SimpliSafe Camera Batteries Last?
SimpliSafe vs. Ring: Which Home Security System is Best Suited for Your Needs?
The Best Plug-in Outdoor Security Lights to Keep Your Home Safe
Everything You Need to Know About Residential Laser Grid Security Systems