Are you planning on replacing the windows of your home? If you search for replacement windows, you might be overwhelmed with the different types, finishes, and materials available.
After determining which type of replacement window you’ll get, the next step is determining what material. The two most popular options in the market are vinyl or PVC and aluminum.
Choosing the right material for your new windows ultimately depends on your needs and preferences. To find out which would better suit your home, here are the advantages, disadvantages, and costs of vinyl and aluminum windows.
Comparing Vinyl and Aluminum Windows: 7 Factors
Durability and Lifespan
If you’re looking for a sturdy window with a long lifespan, then aluminum windows are more durable and secure. This type of window can last for four decades or more when properly maintained. With a better build strength, it offers structural advantages and allows for more glass, providing better views. This would be perfect for sliding or picture windows with no frames blocking the view while letting more natural light in your home. Unlike vinyl windows, aluminum also doesn’t degrade.
If you’re looking for a sturdy window with a long lifespan, then aluminum windows are more durable and secure. This type of window can last for four decades or more when properly maintained. With a better build strength, it offers structural advantages and allows for more glass, providing better views. This would be perfect for sliding or picture windows with no frames blocking the view while letting more natural light in your home. Unlike vinyl windows, aluminum also doesn’t degrade.
Appearance
For the style, vinyl windows give a more traditional vibe while aluminum windows are more modern. PVC windows have a basic and simple look, which would probably suit rustic homes better. On the other hand, aluminum windows are clean and sleek, looking more unique.
An aluminum window is thinner since it requires less framework, but as mentioned above, it is more durable. So if you prefer a slimmer window, then this material is better suited for you.
However, aluminum windows don’t weather nicely. It can get rusty, which will ruin the look of your home’s exterior. Unlike vinyl windows, you cannot paint the frame, so you would probably need to replace it.
Customization
Aluminum windows look more unique, and that’s probably because their style is more customizable. On the other hand, the frame of vinyl windows can be painted, which makes it easier to change for those who want to keep updating the design of their windows.
Maintenance
Compared to aluminum windows, vinyl windows are easier to maintain. They still need to be maintained, since they can warp when it gets too hot or cold. Caulking can prolong its lifespan, but if vinyl windows do get damaged, these are also easier to repair.
Aluminum requires more upkeep since it needs to be lubricated, specifically the movable parts such as the runners and track, to take advantage of the long lifespan and durability. If they don’t get cleaned regularly, you would have a hard time opening and closing the window. This window can also get easily rusty, as well as form mold if condensation forms on it. Wipe it off to prevent it from rusting and other issues.
Energy Efficient
If you want windows that are more energy-efficient, vinyl windows, especially high-quality ones, are a better choice. It doesn’t conduct heat nor gets cold, making it a great insulator, and helps regulate the temperature inside your home. If it reduces heat transfer and can insulate, then you can save on your electricity and heating bill.
On the other hand, aluminum windows do not provide the same energy-efficiency. They conduct heat and can warm up a room, which would require the cooling system to work more.
Fortunately, some aluminum windows are advancing to become more energy-efficient thanks to today’s technology. For example, this can have a double glaze or other coatings to provide better insulation.
Installation
Since vinyl is flexible, it is easier to install. It can contract and expand easily into the opening. It is also quick to install. But for aluminum windows, these need to have the exact measurements. The window cannot be installed properly if the numbers are off. This will take more time to install and will require additional materials such as caulk.
Cost
Vinyl windows are more affordable than aluminum windows. Vinyl windows can cost between $450 and $730, with an installation cost ranging from $75 to $200. On the other hand, the price of aluminum windows is around $650 to $930, with installation costs ranging from $125 to $350.
An aluminum window costs more, but considering its durability and customization, the price would pay off in the long run. So if you’re planning to not replace your window for a long time, it would be more cost-effective to get an aluminum window. On the other hand, PVC is a great material for short-term windows.
But if you do opt for vinyl windows, make sure to avoid buying low-end ones. You would be sacrificing the quality, lifespan, and energy savings you would get from a more expensive yet better vinyl window.
Vinyl vs. Aluminum: Comparison Table
To help you see which one is more advantageous based on the factor, here is a summary of what was mentioned above. In the end, it will come down to your preference and needs. Determine which factors are more important and see which one is better suited for your home.
FACTOR | Material | NOTES |
|---|---|---|
Durability | Aluminum | The material is stronger and has better build strength. |
Lifespan | Aluminum | This window can last for four decades or more. |
Appearance | Preference | A vinyl window has a basic and simple traditional look while aluminum offers a sleek and modern vibe. |
Customization | Preference | Aluminum windows come in different styles while vinyl window frames can be repainted. |
Maintenance | Vinyl | Vinyl windows require less upkeep. |
Energy Efficient | Vinyl | This material acts as an insulator and doesn’t conduct heat. |
Installation | Vinyl | Vinyl windows are flexible while aluminum windows require the exact measurements. |
Cost | Vinyl | This window is less expensive than aluminum. |
Whichever window you choose, you can only take advantage of these benefits if they are installed properly. That’s why after deciding, the next step is looking for a contractor to install your window. If you haven’t found one yet, I operate a partner network that covers nationwide. I think you'll find my partner contractors are more responsive and professional than most. Click the “Get Free Quotes” button below to get estimates from window installers in your area.
FIND LOCAL PROS FOR YOUR HOME PROJECT
After submitting your quote request, you'll be contacted by a few of their local contractors, who are eager to earn your business!